M360 Compass

M360 Compass · Management insights

Company Culture: What Do Your Teams Really Experience?

· 7 min

Written by M360 Compass

Four colleagues having an open team discussion around a meeting table.
AI-generated illustration

Company culture is how people make sense of situations, make decisions and work together. You can see it in everyday behaviour, including how people respond to a mistake, hear out a disagreement, recognize a contribution or decide what can wait when workloads collide.

Written values give people a point of reference. When a client file goes off track or two urgent jobs compete for the same time, the way people respond shows how those values guide their work. To start changing a practice, choose one of those situations and agree on something your team can try this week.

What makes up company culture?

Edgar H. Schein and Peter Schein describe three levels for understanding organizational culture. Organizational Culture and Leadership, fifth edition, “The Structure of Culture”. Wiley’s book listing.

A company can say it values collaboration while sales commits to a delivery date without consulting operations. If it keeps happening, ask what drives the decision. Does asking for time to check capacity look like a lack of initiative? What reason do the teams have to check with one another? Agree on when to confirm capacity and who makes the call when needs conflict. A RACI matrix can help clarify those roles.

Four moments that reveal your culture

Watch what happens in the moment and how the manager follows up in the days afterwards. The follow-up helps you understand what the team will take away from the experience.

One question to ask and one action to try in each situation
Situation and questionFirst action for the manager
Someone reports a mistake.
What made it easy or hard to speak up?
Thank the person for reporting it. Work together to identify what needs immediate attention and what you need to understand.
A disagreement comes up.
Who should be heard before we decide?
Ask for a different view. Explain the decision and the consideration that mattered most.
Someone asks for help.
What support would help them get back on track?
Agree on specific help and a time to check whether it was enough.
Priorities conflict.
Who makes the call, and what work will have to wait?
Name the decision-maker. Tell the people affected what will be postponed.

Combine care, psychological safety and accountability

Psychological safety is a shared belief within a team that people can ask a question, raise a concern or admit a mistake without expecting humiliation or unfair consequences for speaking up. In a study of 51 teams at one manufacturing company, Amy Edmondson found an association between psychological safety and learning behaviours such as asking for help or seeking feedback. Psychological Safety and Learning Behavior in Work Teams, 1999.

A manager shows care by asking questions and offering support after hearing the answers. The same manager sets clear expectations and follows up on commitments. In an interview published by Harvard Business School, Edmondson explains why employees need to share what they know and what worries them when uncertainty is high. Leading in Tough Times.

“We’re clear about the result we need, and we haven’t reached it yet. What got in your way? Let’s look at what’s within your control, what the organization needs to address and what support would help. Then we can agree on the next step.”

Use a one-on-one meeting to understand what support the person needs and set a check-in date. If the conversation is part of a performance review, start with observable evidence and agree on what the employee and manager will each do next.

Put company values into practice in four steps

  1. Choose a real situation. Pick a recent event and describe what happened with the people involved.
  2. Agree on the expected behaviour. Decide together what someone should do the next time it happens. Make the action specific enough that coworkers can tell when it happens.
  3. Agree on a simple record. Use something you already have, such as a decision log. Keep the details that matter and make them available to the people who need them.
  4. Review what happened. Look at a few examples. Ask what helped, what was difficult and what the team could try next.

To put respect for other people’s time into practice, a team could use this rule. “When we change a priority, we also say which work will move back and who needs to know.” At the next meeting, review a decision and check who found out and when. The guide to following up on meeting decisions offers a simple way to record commitments and revisit them.

A fictional example from a Quebec small business

A services company says people should help one another. When an urgent client file arrives, the manager turns to the same experienced employees. Their colleagues see the urgent work getting done. They rarely see what those employees now have to finish later.

The manager tries something different. Before assigning an urgent file, they ask the employee what would have to wait. They agree on a realistic workload, set a new deadline and notify the colleagues affected.

At the next check-in, the team reviews two files. Who was supposed to contact the client? Which commitments were kept? Did the person taking over understand why the original work was delayed? The answers help the manager decide what to adjust before trying the practice elsewhere.

Improve one practice over 90 days

Days 1 to 30 — Listen and choose

Hear from people affected by the situation, including those who deal with the consequences of decisions. Choose a recurring situation and define the behaviour the team will try.

Days 31 to 60 — Practise and learn

Try the behaviour in a few real cases. Take a few minutes to discuss what helped and what made it difficult. Identify what the manager needs to make possible, such as access to information or time to consult another team.

Days 61 to 90 — Adjust and make it part of the work

Revise the practice based on what happened. Agree on who will keep it going and when you will check it again. If new employees need to learn it, explain and practise it during their 30-60-90 day onboarding plan. The 90 days give you time to experiment and learn. Shared habits change at their own pace.

How can you tell whether the culture is improving?

A single measure tells you only part of the story. A favourable average can coexist with difficulties in one department or among people who rarely respond. Compare what employees say with what happens at work.

Gallup’s Q12 meta-analysis reports relationships between employee engagement and several outcomes at the work-unit level, including productivity and turnover. These associations describe patterns across units. They cannot establish that a specific initiative caused a change in your own business. Gallup, Q12 Meta-Analysis, 11th edition.

Where M360 Compass can support the team’s work

RoleAlign™ helps you document roles, responsibilities and expectations when it is unclear who should make a decision. Momentum lets you record decisions and track actions with an owner and a due date.

Performance and development helps connect feedback with skills, development actions and follow-ups. M360 Pulse surveys can help start a conversation with employees. Before launching a survey, check who can respond, who can see the results and how you will report back to the team.

Common questions about company culture

Where should we start when improving company culture?

Choose a recurring situation that makes work harder. Hear from the people affected, agree on one behaviour to try and schedule a short review after the first few cases.

How can we tell whether people live the company’s values?

Ask several people to describe a recent event that put a value to the test. Compare what they say with the decisions and actions you can observe. Pick one gap the team can address.

Can we measure company culture with a single indicator?

One measure can flag a change, but it offers little context about why it happened. Bring together employee feedback, observations of work and a review of commitments. Discuss any gaps with the people involved.

Who is responsible for company culture?

Senior leaders set expectations and make the major decisions. Managers turn those expectations into everyday practices, teams help shape how they work and HR supports consistency across departments. Senior leaders remain responsible for the conditions and trade-offs that teams cannot control.

Start with a conversation

Company culture grows through the conversations we’re willing to have, the commitments we keep and the way we support people when work gets difficult.

Want to see how to keep decisions and follow-ups visible? Bring an example from your team to a M360 Compass demo.